Local

US Judge Says Murdered Israeli Teen’s Family “Took Risk By Living In West Bank”

A district court judge in Washington was told to issue a new ruling by a U.S. appeals court regarding a lawsuit that parents of a murdered Israeli teen filed against Iran and Syria. The district court judge had issued an original ruling stating that the family could only sue for a relatively small sum in compensation because it had endangered itself by choosing to live in Judea and Samaria.

The case, which was largely symbolic in nature, was brought to the court by U.S. citizens Racheli and Avi Fraenkel after their son Naftali disappeared in June 2014 together with two other boys, Gilad Shaer and Eyal Yifrach. The boys had been hitchhiking from a bus stop in Gush Etzion, when the inadvertently entered a car that was being driven by members of a Hamas terror cell, who was looking to kidnap and kill Jews.

“We filed the suit to ‘harass the bad guys,’” Racheli Fraenkel told the Israeli media outlet  Ynet. “There are many ways to fight terror, and in this case it’s about limiting the economic steps they can take.”

The Fraenkels live in the town of Nof Ayalon, a town located in central Israel. The town lies close to the green line but does not cross it.

Fraenkel said she that the couple had no real expectations of receiving any money from the terror-supporting states and that the issue was more symbolic than actual.

The judge who presided over the case, Judge Rosemary Collyer, concluded that the family had the right to sue both countries for their son’s murder and said in the ruling that: “Iran and Syria did indeed provide help and resources to Hamas and aided in the kidnapping and murder of Naftali.”

Collyer even said that Naftali’s death was: “a tragedy that no sum can ever compensate for.” However, she rejected the claim for $340 million, ruling that $4.1 million was appropriate due to the family’s choice of living in a dangerous area.

The Fraenkels appealed Collyer’s decision and asked the judge to reconsider her verdict.

Collyer refused and explained that: “The plaintiffs took on themselves the risks of living beyond Israel’s Green Line and sending Naftali Fraenkel another 40 km into the West Bank to a high school in Gush Etzion, six km from the city of Hebron.”

Collyer noted that Naftali was not chosen by Hamas due to the fact that he was a U.S. citizen who was “mistakenly caught in the conflict,” but that he as well as the other boys were targeted “because they were Jewish and Israeli youths. These facts do not diminish the plaintiffs’ grief or loss, but they can influence the assistance available to them when viewed through the lens of civil tort liability,” she wrote.

Racheli said that the judge’s response was “outrageous. The children were on their way from school. What responsibility did the boys have for their deaths?”

The family turned to the federal appeals court. Attorneys Nitsana Darshan-Leitner of the Israel Law Center and Robert Tulchin argued that Collyer had exceeded her authority and included unacceptable considerations in weighing the compensation request.

The federal appeals court accepted most of the arguments put forth by the attorneys last month and ordered the case to be sent back to Collyer. They instructed the district court to not attach guilt to the victims and issued a directive that the sum of the compensation should be increased.

(YWN Israel Desk – Jerusalem)

Click to add a comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Local

More in Local

dce6f47f352d74b170fdac2ac1588792.jpg

Obama Gives Trump Sharp Rebuke In Mandela Address On Values

adminJuly 17, 2018
ec3a8900dcb923dba4b9eae7f19771bf.jpg

FRIGHTENING FOOTAGE: Las Vegas Police On Wild Pursuit And Scary Shootout

adminJuly 17, 2018
fc9ea9e9f06d7dc461874e0ece270c70.jpg

US Intel Chief Stands By Assessment Of Russian Meddling, Despite Trump Doubts

adminJuly 17, 2018
df19061576cede4f8ff0f53d07c50f77.jpg

2 CVS Workers Lose Jobs After Cops Called On Black Customer

adminJuly 17, 2018
c393a1f20798ca7b7a1e86aa2b155d32.jpg

Report: Six Syrians And Three Iranians Killed In Israeli Attack

adminJuly 16, 2018
99f2e8c955870432800069fa37342088.jpg

Prime Time: A Day Of Deals At Amazon, And At Its Rivals

adminJuly 16, 2018
6e00a149d70e5ee41ac83ce8a7a829c8.jpg

VIDEO: Mobster Miraculously Survives Hit-Job On Bronx Street

adminJuly 16, 2018
e4d2939a0f39f08654a8bb6a2c74fa58.jpg

Police: Suspect Dead After Wounding 3 Kansas City Officers

adminJuly 16, 2018
52a983eb207b840c925eb2f11bcf148b.jpg

Producers Plan Movie About Thai Cave Rescue

adminJuly 13, 2018